Is there any real proof that the little "whistles" you can install on the front
of your car will keep the deer away while you drive down the road? I read
recently that the National Forest Service has them on their vehicles---
but do they really work? Why? The advertisement says it will not bother pets, but
will be highly effective on deer? How?
Thanks for any info!
I don't know if they really work but our police department swears by
them. We have lots of deer in my neighborhood and I DON'T know anyone
who has hit a deer while whistles were in place but I don't know many
people who hit deer period. Statistically this anecdotal evidence suggest
suggests that there is no difference. Put in another way, if most cars
were equipped with whistles and deer were not repelled by them, most a
accidents would involve "whistled" cars and whistle-free cars would seem
more accident free. I do not know if studies have been performed. Maybe
you can call the company and they can cite a study or maybe your local
sheriff can help.
Michael B Lomonaco
As it turns out, this HAS been studied, and those little whistles
do NOT affect deer at all. The sound produced by these whistles
is a high frequency sound, quite out of the hearing range of the
deer! Deer have a relatively low frequency range of hearing similar
Tom F Ihde
Click here to return to the Biology Archives
Update: June 2012